National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA)
Published: 2018-07-17
Total Pages: 152
Get eBook
This report presents an analysis and performance comparison of five system identification algorithms. The methods are presented in the context of identifying a frequency-domain transfer matrix for the higher harmonic control (HHC) of helicopter vibration. The five system identification algorithms include three previously proposed methods: (1) the weighted-least- squares-error approach (in moving-block format), (2) the Kalman filter method, and (3) the least-mean-squares (LMS) filter method. In addition there are two new ones: (4) a generalized Kalman filter method and (5) a generalized LMS filter method. The generalized Kalman filter method and the generalized LMS filter method were derived as extensions of the classic methods to permit identification by using more than one measurement per identification cycle. Simulation results are presented for conditions ranging from the ideal case of a stationary transfer matrix and no measurement noise to the more complex cases involving both measurement noise and transfer-matrix variation. Both open-loop identification and closed- loop identification were simulated. Closed-loop mode identification was more challenging than open-loop identification because of the decreasing signal-to-noise ratio as the vibration became reduced. The closed-loop simulation considered both local-model identification, with measured vibration feedback and global-model identification with feedback of the identified uncontrolled vibration. The algorithms were evaluated in terms of their accuracy, stability, convergence properties, computation speeds, and relative ease of implementation. Jacklin, Stephen A. Ames Research Center ALGORITHMS; FEEDBACK CONTROL; HARMONIC CONTROL; HELICOPTERS; KALMAN FILTERS; MATRICES (MATHEMATICS); ROTARY WING AIRCRAFT; CONVERGENCE; ERRORS; FEEDBACK; FREQUENCIES; IDENTIFYING; MEAN SQUARE VALUES; SIGNAL TO NOISE RATIOS; SIMULATION; STABILITY; SYSTEM IDENTIFICATION; VIBRATION...